The Tax Authority's "Ten Commandments" - Full Guide to Recognized Property Separation

What Are the Tax Authority's "Ten Commandments"?

When a married couple signs a prenuptial agreement with property separation, the natural assumption is that each spouse is treated as an independent unit for tax purposes. But the Israel Tax Authority does not accept the separation automatically. Section 9(b) of the Land Taxation Law (Appreciation and Purchase), 1963, establishes the family unit presumption - spouses and their minor children are considered a single purchaser for purchase tax purposes.

To rebut this presumption, the Tax Authority developed a list of criteria known informally as the "Ten Commandments." These are not merely recommendations - they are the conditions that the tax assessor and real estate tax officer examine to determine whether your property separation is genuine.

---

The Legal Background - Rulings That Shaped the Approach

Before diving into the list, it helps to understand where this strict approach came from.

The Shalemi Ruling (VA 1281/04, 2008)

In the Shalemi case, the Appeals Committee under the Land Taxation Law examined a couple who had signed a prenup with full property separation. One spouse purchased an additional apartment and claimed "sole apartment" status for purchase tax purposes. The committee held that an agreement on paper is not enough - the actual conduct must be examined. Several practical tests were established:

• Do the spouses maintain separate bank accounts?
• Are there mutual guarantees?
• Are assets registered separately?
• Is the separation consistent over time?

This ruling laid the groundwork for what later became the "Ten Commandments."

The Blank-Rosenbaum Ruling (VA 15352-09-12, 2014)

The Blank-Rosenbaum ruling went further. The committee held that even when a prenup is legally valid and court-approved, the Tax Authority may refuse to recognize it if actual conduct does not match. In that case, the spouses maintained a joint bank account, signed mutual guarantees, and did not separate their investments. The committee stated: "A prenuptial agreement is not sufficient. Genuine, complete, and consistent property separation must be demonstrated."

---

The "Ten Commandments" - The Full List

Here are the 10 criteria the Tax Authority examines. The more you satisfy, the higher the chance your separation will be recognized:

1. Separate Bank Accounts

Each spouse maintains a personal bank account. Salary goes into the personal account, investments are managed from it, and personal expenses come out of it. A joint account for household management is permitted - but it must be secondary, not primary.

2. Separate Credit Cards

Each spouse holds credit cards in their name only. A supplementary card on a spouse's account - even a "family card" - can undermine recognition.

3. No Mutual Guarantees

One spouse does not sign as guarantor for the other's loans, mortgages, or financial obligations. This is one of the most important criteria and one that many couples fail - banks demand spousal guarantees, and couples sign without understanding the implications.

4. Clear Ownership Documentation

Every asset - apartment, vehicle, investment portfolio - is registered solely in the name of the spouse it belongs to. If there is a jointly owned asset, the agreement must explicitly define each party's share.

5. Separate Investments

Investment portfolios, provident funds, pension funds, and continuing education funds are all managed separately. Each spouse makes independent investment decisions.

6. Separate Tax Filings

Where applicable (for example, when one spouse is self-employed), each spouse files an independent annual tax return. Even salaried employees can request separate tax calculation.

7. Separate Financing for Major Purchases

Purchasing an apartment, car, or any significant asset is funded from the purchasing spouse's personal funds. If the other spouse transfers money for the purchase, the separation is broken.

8. No Commingling of Funds

Money is not routinely transferred between personal accounts. A one-time, documented transfer (for example, a formal loan between spouses) may be acceptable, but routine transfers are not.

9. Consistency Over Time

The property separation did not begin a month before purchasing the apartment. The Tax Authority examines a period of years, not weeks. The longer the separation has been in place, the more credible it is.

10. Good Faith

The agreement was made for genuine reasons - a desire to protect property, maintain financial independence, manage risk - and not solely as a tax strategy. The Tax Authority looks for an agreement that reflects reality, not a document created only to save tax.

---

What Happens If You Don't Meet the Criteria?

The simple answer: you pay more tax. Much more.

Here is a numerical example. Suppose one spouse already owns an apartment, and the other wants to purchase an apartment for NIS 2,000,000:

Without recognized separation (additional apartment):

With recognized separation (sole apartment):

The difference: approximately NIS 159,000 - on a single apartment.

For a NIS 3,000,000 apartment, the difference jumps to approximately NIS 204,000. For a NIS 4,000,000 apartment? Around NIS 284,000.

---

The Most Common Mistakes That Disqualify Recognition

Based on the experience of attorneys specializing in this field, these are the mistakes that cause applications to be rejected:

1. The "household harmony" account - Spouses who manage all their money from one account "because it's convenient." Even with a prenup, the separation is not credible.

2. Mutual mortgage guarantees - Banks demand it, couples sign. But a mutual guarantee directly contradicts property separation. The solution: Take the mortgage in one spouse's name only, with alternative collateral.

3. A "family" credit card - A supplementary card on a spouse's account. Seems harmless, but the Tax Authority treats it as commingling.

4. Suspicious timing - A prenup signed weeks before purchasing an apartment. The Tax Authority interprets this as "artificial tax planning" and rejects the application.

5. Transfers between accounts - A monthly "loan" of NIS 5,000 from one spouse to the other. Without a formal loan agreement, this is commingling.

---

How Noberu Handles This - Step 6 in the Questionnaire

At Noberu, Step 6 of the questionnaire (tax planning) is entirely dedicated to this topic. In this step:

• You select the property regime - full property separation, partial separation, or community property
• You define which assets are separate - including account numbers, land registry details, and values
• You plan your financial conduct - the system guides you to create a structure that meets the "Ten Commandments"
• You prepare for registration - after signing, you receive detailed instructions for registering with the Tax Authority

The resulting agreement contains specific clauses tailored to the Tax Authority's requirements - including the definition of separate accounts, a prohibition on mutual guarantees, and clear separation mechanisms.

---

The Bottom Line

The Tax Authority's "Ten Commandments" are not just a checklist - they are the key to saving hundreds of thousands of shekels on purchase tax. A prenup without meeting these criteria is like insurance without coverage - a document that looks good on paper but doesn't work when you need it.

At Noberu, we don't just draft an agreement - we build it to withstand the Tax Authority's scrutiny. Because a prenup that isn't recognized for tax purposes only covers half the story.

Start the process - a prenup that meets the "Ten Commandments" →